Faith Can Move Mountains... But Dynamite Works Better

Monday, July 23, 2012

The Dark Knight Triumphant

The Dark Knight returns one more time in the finale to director Christopher Nolan’s Batman trilogy, The Dark Knight Rises, and like the first two films in the set, the movie does not disappoint. It transcends the comic book adaptation, as more than an action thriller. It’s a cerebral film, taking on big themes and psychological issues, and it succeeds in every way.

It’s been eight years since the events of the previous film, since Batman (Christian Bale) took the blame for the actions of the fallen District Attorney Harvey Dent (not to mention his death). Bruce Wayne has given up the mantle of the Bat and withdrawn into himself, worn down physically and emotionally. He spends much of his time holed up in his manor, while the city he once protected has rejected him. His company has seen better days, and is now steeply on a decline. All he has left for company is his butler and father figure Alfred (Michael Caine), who worries about how deeply Bruce has been battered by the events of the last few years.

Commissioner Gordon (Gary Oldman) knows the truth of his innocence, but is obliged to maintain the facade of Batman as an outlaw, and he has his own issues to deal with, from political concerns and senior officers jockeying for his post to an arrogant belief in the city that major crime is a problem of the past.
Into the mix come two wild cards. Selina Kyle (Anne Hathaway) is a cat burglar with an agenda all her own. And Bane (Tom Hardy) is a ruthless anarchist who unleashes hell on the city, in a series of attacks meant to draw out and destroy the Dark Knight, which is only the beginning of what he has in mind.

The finale of the series is a harrowing journey into darkness. The film, scripted by Nolan, his brother Jonathan Nolan, and David S. Goyer, takes on themes that are very prevalent today: the conflict between rampant capitalism and rights of the people, the fear of terrorism, the role of justice in the world. It follows a hero who’s just a man, at his lowest point, and asks the question of what can bring him back. There are influences from some of the biggest Batman stories of the comics: The Dark Knight Returns, Knightfall, and No Man’s Land are obvious ones. There are also shades of the storming of the Bastille and the French Revolution underlying the story.

The production values of the film are, as before, well worth it. The cinematography is spectacular; there are camera shots throughout the film that will leave you breathless. The special effects serve the story, and not the other way around; explosions for instance, in this film, are done properly, unlike the wildly over-exaggerated garbage we’d see out of a hack like Michael Bay (yes, Michael Bay, you are a hack of the first order. You are a hack in a hack class all of your own). And the score by Hans Zimmer (this time on his own, without his collaborator for the first two films, James Newton Howard) brings back some of the previous themes but goes off in other strong directions. Nolan has chosen his crew well, once again.

The cast itself is splendid in their roles. Marion Cotillard is a newcomer as Miranda Tate, a tycoon with an energy device that may be the salvation of Wayne Enterprises. Cotillard is a gifted French actress who you might recall from Inception, another Nolan film. She plays the role with sublety and nuance, and fits very well into the tapestry of the film. Another Inception veteran is Joseph Gordon-Levitt, playing John Blake, an inherently decent Gotham Police officer. There is a curious quality to his nature, and a basic integrity to him. He becomes the audience point of view character, the everyman we can relate to, who steps up to do right just because it’s the right thing.

The returning veteran players inhabit their roles once more perfectly. Gary Oldman as Gordon is as good as ever; Oldman is one of the great character actors of our time, and as Batman’s one time ally, we see a man who’s deeply unhappy at having to publicly be against the Batman early on, and then finds himself confronting the worst possible crisis of his life. Morgan Freeman returns as Lucius Fox, the Wayne executive and father figure to Bruce who’s provided much of the Bat tech in the past. There continues to be a wise strength in his portrayal of the character. And Michael Caine is very much the heart of the film, a foster father to Bruce Wayne, the guiding conscience, the Horatio to Bruce’s Hamlet.

Tom Hardy is another Inception veteran, and in that film, he completely stole the movie from the star, Leonardo DiCaprio (admittedly not that hard to do). He plays the monstrous Bane just as I’d expect him to be: a clever and brutal man, hidden behind a strange mask, a ferocious force of nature, and utterly nihilistic. Bane first appeared in the comics in the aforementioned Knightfall story, and has appeared in film, in the cinematic abomination that was Batman & Robin, where the character was a brainless idiot who happened to be nothing more than muscle for the two primary villains. For that and many other Bat-reasons, Joel Schumacher has more than earned his place in the seventh circle of Hell. This Bane is a decisive, bold leader, intelligent and sadistic, willing to do anything to achieve his objectives.

Anne Hathaway plays Catwoman, though she’s never once called that through the film. It’s probably impossible to outdo Michelle Pfeiffer’s take on the character, so Hathaway doesn’t even try, instead playing the character closer to the comic book version, a woman who's straddling the line between hero and villain. She brings a strong energy to the role, and her character draws Bruce out of the darkness he has descended into. She's got the look of the character just right, and gives the character just the right dramatic touches in terms of personality.

Christian Bale gives arguably his best performance of the trilogy in this film. His Batman has become brooding and withdrawn, consumed by losses in his life and the rejection of the people he once vowed to protect. The character is at the lowest ebb, and has to find his way out of despair and back to himself; he has to reinvest himself in his mission, to once again be the hero to a city that doesn't deserve him. Bale has an intensity and a drive as an actor that makes him fascinating to watch, and he inhabits the dual role of Bruce Wayne the tycoon and Batman the driven vigilante perfectly. In each of these films he’s understood the basic truth: the real man is the one driven by his own tragedy to wage war on crime, to seek justice, and the facade or mask is the carefree socialite.

Nolan has given us three outstanding, spectacular adaptations in this trilogy. The Dark Knight Rises is exhilarating, demanding, and rewarding, and not only is it a great comic adaptation and thrilling action film, it's also one of the best films of the year. It makes us care about the characters, surprises us in unexpected ways, and makes us ask ourselves questions. It makes us think, because it’s a film with depth.
Something that can never be suggested of Joel Schumacher, who, rumour has it, still wants to make his (self described) masterpiece Batman & Robin & Batgirl: More Bat Nipple Costumes, All The Time.


  1. Great review!

    I'm planning to see it. In my opinion, Christian Bale is the only one of the actors who's played Bats to get the character right. And I love Anne Hathaway.

    I will admit that it's going to be difficult to watch it without thinking of the events that took place in Aurora....

  2. Wonderful review. Thought it was a damn fine cinema experience. I would, however, say that Batman Begins is still my favorite of the three. TDKR is my second favorite, and Dark Knight third. The second one blew me away when I first watched it in the theater, because there'd never been a truly gritty Batman movie experience. Heath Ledger's Joker performance also swept me away. But after multiple re-watchings, I just don't think the story holds up to Begins.

    There are some inconsistencies in the third as well, and Bane isn't close to being as compelling of a bady as Ledger or Liam N. in my opinion. Ultimately, this is like arguing for a favorite child in my eyes, though. Nolan did more for Bat-fans than I'd ever have imagined possible in the Hollywood cash machine era.

  3. As most of you know, I'm not a huge super-hero fan...and I really don't like Christian Bale...However, I did like the last one...

    I think I'll wait until it comes out on the movie network to watch this one.

  4. I am always interested in your reviews. So when I see a new movie coming out I wonder if you or Norma will review it.
    Since I haven't watched the whole series I guess I need to hit Netflix and catch up, fast !
    Since you liked the movie so much I wonder why the bad review came out just before the movie, with all the back and forth on the internet.

    I seem to watch the animated series. I love Batman The Animated series, the artwork is very 40's film noir, dark and edgy. Love the artwork.
    I also watched the Batman Beyond a newer series and through it saw Batman old sad and living alone. I wondered how he went from charming Bruce Wayne (with problems no doubt) to a recluse. The new kid drags him kicking and screaming back sort of.

    @Norma, As for Aurora, bad thing happen because of people... the movie will always be connected to events of the night and like you said it will be difficult.
    If I connected everything I would move from Tucson and never shop at the Safeway down the street either.
    Life is very difficult sometimes.

    cheers, parsnip

  5. Fantabulous review! Hack? Hack class? You're funny, Sir Wills.


  6. Great review!! I can't wait to see it! I love Christian Bale and Ann Hathaway:).

  7. Excellent review! William, you are great at reviewing both books and movies! I hope I can see it soon. Take care!

  8. @Norma: You'll love it. It is going to be hard to seperate the film from the tragedy though...

    @EJ: the trilogy is magnificent. Batman Begins has my favourite ever Bat villain, Scarecrow... but I found Katie Holmes to be the one weak spot in the cast. Regardless, the quality of all three films is really consistent.

    @Beth: this is far better than anything featuring Mr. Sparkles! You must see it!

  9. @Parsnip: I loved the animated series. Kevin Conroy's voice as Batman was just right as it ought to be, and Mark Hamill's Joker was outright terrifying. I have seen bits and pieces of Batman Beyond, which has also made it to the comics universe as well.

    @Shelly: Bay is a hack!

    @Maria: You'll love it!

    @Lena: it's well worth it!

  10. Nice review. I'm really behind on these movies.

  11. Well worth it to catch up, Kelly!

    Christian Bale and his wife turned up in Colorado and visited some of the families. Slipped in largely unnoticed, so there's very little footage of it. They made it about the families, not about themselves. Very classy.

    if it had been Tom Cruise, he'd have had his publicists call every entertainment outlet to have crews following him around all over, and Scientology disciples trying to recruit people, but then in Tom's world, everything is about Tom.

  12. I loved it. Bane was a super scary villain. I loved cat woman.

    Good review.


Comments and opinions always welcome. If you're a spammer, your messages aren't going to last long here, even if they do make it past the spam filters. Keep it up with the spam, and I'll send Dick Cheney after you.